Migrating from Tunnel Proxy to Per-App TunnelVMware Workspace ONE UEM 1905 and later
As technology evolves and remote access becomes a cornerstone of working culture, customers are moving away from traditional full-device VPNs and are looking more towards app tunnels as the new standard. The VMware Workspace ONE Tunnel application has long been enabling customers to have secure access to their internal resources while minimizing the threat vectors to your network.
VMware Workspace ONE® has provided two related solutions that are part of the VMware Unified Access Gateway™ software appliance:
- Tunnel Proxy - enables SDK-built applications to set up an app-level proxy connection to internal sites, leveraging HTTPS encryption and certificate authentication. The VMware Workspace ONE Web app embeds Proxy support by default.
- (Per) App Tunnel - enables an SSL VPN connection on a per-app basis for any public or internal application for managed devices. The Workspace ONE Tunnel application resides on a device, and an administrator explicitly specifies which apps are enabled for Tunnel. Workspace ONE also offers a new Tunnel SDK module as part of the Workspace ONE SDK, which serves as a replacement to the Tunnel Proxy solution. Generally speaking, the Tunnel solution is more secure, has better performance, and has more features than Proxy.
As such, all Tunnel Proxy use cases have been consolidated into the Tunnel service gateway, app, and SDK.
This guide is intended to help Workspace ONE UEM administrators currently using Tunnel Proxy to migrate to unmanaged Tunnel.
Both current and new administrators of existing production environments can benefit from using this guide. Hands-on experience and knowledge of VMware Workspace ONE® UEM, VMware Unified Access Gateway, VMware Tunnel Edge Service, and Workspace ONE Tunnel app configuration is assumed.
Tunnel SDK Use Cases
The use of the Tunnel SDK module is primarily designed for native mobile applications on unmanaged devices that require communication with a resource on the internal network, like internal websites, REST API servers, desktops, and others.
Organizations that cannot manage end-user devices (such as contractors or BYOD) through mobile device management (MDM) and require access to corporate information through native mobile applications, can leverage:
- Workspace ONE Web app to enable access to internal websites.
- Workspace ONE SDK embedded into the company internal applications, to enable access to internal resources.
How Tunnel SDK Module Works
Tunnel Module (aka Tunnel SDK) on Workspace ONE SDK
A new Tunnel module was added to the Workspace ONE SDK to enable native mobile apps to perform app tunneling on unmanaged iOS and Android devices without the need for the Workspace ONE Tunnel application.
The Tunnel SDK leverages Device Traffic Rules defined in VMware Workspace ONE® UEM. When App Tunnel Mode is set to VMware Tunnel as part of the default SDK security policies, a compatibility option is available to support apps that have not yet migrated from Proxy to Tunnel.
The Workspace ONE Web app, starting with version 7.6, has the Workspace ONE SDK that includes the new Tunnel module, allowing the use of Workspace ONE Web based on Per-App Tunnel.
When using the Tunnel SDK, the Workspace ONE Tunnel app and assignment of a Per-App VPN profile to the app are not required, which enables the use of unmanaged devices (MAM mode).
Enrollment Method Considerations
In MAM mode use cases, you must deploy SDK-based apps through the HUB app to receive the SDK configuration to perform app tunneling.
On devices managed through MDM, use a VPN profile payload and Workspace ONE Tunnel to achieve app tunneling.
Server, Certificate, and Application Requirements
- Workspace ONE UEM 1905 and later
- VMware Tunnel (Per-App) configured in Workspace ONE UEM with the following configuration for certificate authentication:
- Client Authentication for Tunnel only supports AirWatch CA; third-party CAs are not currently supported.
- Server Authentication may use either a public SSL certificate or an AirWatch CA.
- VMware Unified Access Gateway 3.9 and above
- VMware Tunnel (Per-App component) edge service enabled.
- Default SDK profile assigned to the mobile applications, custom SDK profiles are not currently supported.
- For internal applications that leverage Workspace ONE SDK, you must work with your development team to update the SDK to the latest version.
For more information, see:
When using Workspace ONE Web, version 7.6+ of the app is required.
Architecture and Network Considerations
Assuming you already have the VMware Tunnel (Per-App component) edge service enabled on the Unified Access Gateway appliance, nothing changes from an architecture perspective.
The current model requires two open ports for VMware Tunnel edge service in each appliance (basic versus cascade mode):
- Tunnel Proxy requires 2020 on front-end appliance and 2010 on the back-end appliance when deploying in cascade mode.
- Per-App Tunnel most likely configured on 443 or 8443 for the front-end appliance, also on the back-end appliance when using cascade mode deployment.
When you complete the migration steps, the only change to consider is from a network perspective. Only the Per-App Tunnel port must be open on the DMZ. Remove the firewall rules allowing access through TCP 2010 and 2020; they are no longer required.
Basic Mode Configuration
The following diagrams illustrate the architecture required by the current model versus how the architecture will look after the migration based on VMware Tunnel basic mode configuration, which is a single appliance deployment on DMZ.
Cascade Mode Configuration
The next diagrams illustrate the same architecture comparison but now based on VMware Tunnel cascade mode configuration. In cascade mode, traffic from the application on the device to the internal network flows through a front-end appliance deployed on DMZ, followed by another appliance deployed on the Internal Network.
The consolidation of all use cases under VMware Tunnel (Per-App Tunnel) edge service on Unified Access Gateway brings some additional benefits:
- Reduces the number of non-standard ports opened on DMZ.
- Enables the use of Unified Access Gateway High Availability component to load balance Tunnel traffic on port 443.
- Enables the use of multiple edge services (Web Reverse Proxy, Content Gateway, Secure Email Gateway) on the same appliance using a single port (443).
The following steps help you to perform the required changes in Workspace ONE UEM for SDK-based apps to start using Per-App Tunnel features and deactivate the Tunnel Proxy.
Obtaining App Tunnel URLs for Tunnel Proxy
Before you begin, make sure that Tunnel Proxy is deployed in your Workspace ONE UEM environment. Take note of all App Tunnel URLs that are defined for Tunnel Proxy and configured under SDK Security Policies in the Workspace ONE UEM Console.
Tunnel SDK will no longer look for the URLs based on the Security Policy configuration. Instead, you will configure the URLs under Device Traffic Rules.
Configuring Device Traffic Rules based on App Tunnel URLs
You must migrate the App Tunnel URLs used by Tunnel Proxy to Device Traffic Rules and assign them to the applications that leverage the Workspace ONE SDK.
1. Client Authentication
Ensure Client Authentication is configured to use AirWatch CA. Third-party SSL certificates are not supported on unmanaged devices with Tunnel SDK.
2. Device Traffic Rules
Adding Tunnel URLs to the Device Traffic Rules allows SDK-based apps to identify which URLs to proxy the traffic through the Tunnel Service on Unified Access Gateway, leveraging app tunneling.
The example shown uses Workspace ONE Web because it is integrated with Workspace ONE SDK.
- Traffic to
*.corp.internalis tunneled for the Remote Desktop and Workspace ONE Web applications on iOS and Android. However, the behavior will differ because both applications do not use Workspace ONE SDK.
- Workspace ONE Web app was added to the rule, and no VPN Profile is assigned to the app. This ensures that the Tunnel SDK looks for the destination URL to tunnel the traffic, and also works properly on unmanaged devices.
If your Workspace ONE Web app has a VPN Profile assigned, that will work only for managed devices and will require the Workspace ONE Tunnel app to tunnel the traffic.
- If you click Save and Publish at this point, it will not migrate the SDK-based apps from tunnel proxy to app tunneling.
Deactivating Tunnel Proxy on Workspace ONE UEM
After you have completed the required Device Traffic Rules configuration, the next step is to switch off the Tunnel Proxy component for the SDK-based apps on Workspace ONE UEM console.
Set App Tunnel Mode to VMware Tunnel
- Return to the SDK Security Policies configuration and change the App Tunnel Mode to VMware Tunnel.
- Save the configuration.
Switching the configuration tells Workspace ONE SDK which configuration the SDK-based apps will get next time the SDK checks in.
Note: In case the apps do not have the new Tunnel SDK module, you can enable the Tunnel Proxy for Backwards Compatibility option to fetch the existing Proxy configuration.
Deactivate Tunnel Proxy
If your environment does not require backward compatibility with Tunnel Proxy, perform the following steps to deactivate the Tunnel Proxy configuration.
- Navigate to Enterprise Integration > VMware Tunnel Proxy.
- Select Disabled for VMware Tunnel.
- Click Save.
Deactivating App Tunnel Mode effectively transitions the apps to use Per-App Tunnel the next time the end-user relaunches the app. However, the Tunnel Proxy still runs as part of the VMware Tunnel Edge Service on Unified Access Gateway.
The next topic discusses the options to deactivate Tunnel Proxy on Unified Access Gateway.
Deactivating Tunnel Proxy on Unified Access Gateway
When you deactivate the Tunnel Proxy configuration in the Workspace ONE UEM Console, it does not automatically shut down the Tunnel Proxy component on Unified Access Gateway until you restart the VMware Tunnel edge service.
You can force a restart of the Tunnel edge service using one of the following options:
- Access vSphere Web Client and restart the Unified Access Gateway appliance.
- Open the VMware Tunnel Edge Service settings using the Unified Access Gateway Admin UI and re-save the configuration.
As a result of the restart, VMware Tunnel Edge Service communicates with Workspace ONE UEM through API. The service identifies that Tunnel Proxy is deactivated and does not retrieve configuration for the Tunnel Proxy component.
Make sure that you remove the firewall rules that were allowing TCP traffic through ports 2020/2010; they are no longer necessary. The SDK-based apps will communicate through the port configured for Per-App Tunneling.
Summary and Additional Resources
This guide provided steps to migrate from legacy Tunnel Proxy to modern Per-App Tunnel.
By leveraging Per-App Tunnel, you can now enable users from managed and unmanaged devices to access internal applications from their mobile devices. IT administrators can leverage advanced features from Unified Access Gateway such as TLS Port Sharing. That eliminates the requirement to open non-standard ports on DMZ and increase TCO leveraging the High Availability component.
It also provides an extra layer of security to your corporate resources by ensuring that non-authorized apps and devices are unable to connect to your VPN, creating the beginnings of a Zero Trust model for application access.
For more information about Per-App Tunneling, explore the Deploying VMware Workspace ONE Tunnel and Configuring the VMware Tunnel Edge Service tutorials on VMware Unified Access Gateway Activity Path. The activity path provides step-by-step guidance to help you level-up in your Workspace ONE knowledge. You will find everything from beginner to advanced curated assets in the form of articles, videos, and labs.
Additionally, you can check out the VMware Workspace ONE and VMware Horizon Reference Architecture which provides a framework and guidance for architecting an integrated digital workspace using VMware Workspace ONE and VMware Horizon.
About the Author
This guide was written by:
- Andreano Lanusse, End-User-Computing Staff Architect, Technical Marketing, VMware.
The purpose of this tutorial is to assist you. Your feedback is valuable. To comment on this tutorial, contact VMware End-User-Computing Technical Marketing at email@example.com.